Sunday, November 15, 2026

Gemni AI Q&A NIST 9/11 Theory of "multiple floor", "simultaneously" across many floors sounds alot like a Controlled Demolition



The botton line is without hard enidence i.e proof, the story NIST made was fictional. Created by computers and people like a movie. FEMA had better access to the evidence what conclusions did they reach? Why not continue with the 9/11 investigation with FEMA? Your own words describe controlled demolition "• Multiple floors, not a single floor. NIST concluded that intense, multi-floor fires—fueled by office contents after aircraft impacts stripped away fireproofing—caused multiple floors to heat up and sag simultaneously (for example, floors 79 to 83 in WTC 2). A single sagging floor would not have exerted enough force to bring down a tower." anything [simultaneously] is the goal of demolition experts. I wonder if this is why Maximilian Ruppert believes it was a controlled demo.. "a planned procedure"
Your questions get directly to the heart of how the federal in

Is this a good summary NIST's 9/11 theory "A single floor sagged and pulled a single row of perimeter columns inward." ?
9:28 AM
No, that is an oversimplification that misses several critical components of NIST’s actual findings.
While it captures the general physical mechanism (sagging floors pulling exterior columns inward), it gets key details wrong regarding the scale of the damage and the sequence of events documented in the official NIST World Trade Center Investigation. [1]
Where the Summary Falls Short
  • Multiple floors, not a single floor. NIST concluded that intense, multi-floor fires—fueled by office contents after aircraft impacts stripped away fireproofing—caused multiple floors to heat up and sag simultaneously (for example, floors 79 to 83 in WTC 2). A single sagging floor would not have exerted enough force to bring down a tower. [1, 2]
  • An entire exterior wall, not a single row. The sagging floors pulled inward on the columns across one entire face (wall) of the building (the south wall of WTC 1 and the east wall of WTC 2). Once those bowed columns buckled, the instability rapidly spread horizontally across that wall and onto the adjacent walls. [1, 2, 3]
  • Omits the aircraft impact and core weakening. The summary leaves out the crucial prerequisites: the airplanes severed numerous exterior and core columns and stripped off thermal insulation. Additionally, fire-weakened core columns shortened and redistributed their vertical loads onto the perimeter columns, further overloading them before they buckled. [1, 2, 3]
  • Applies only to the Twin Towers, not WTC 7. This mechanism describes WTC 1 and WTC 2. For World Trade Center Building 7, NIST found that thermal expansion of floor beams pushed a girder off its seat, causing an internal critical column (Column 79) to buckle and trigger a progressive collapse. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
A More Accurate One-Sentence Summary
"Aircraft impacts severed columns and stripped fireproofing, allowing multi-floor fires to weaken the core and cause multiple floors to sag, pulling an entire wall of perimeter columns inward until they buckled and triggered a progressive collapse." [1, 2, 3, 4]
You can review the detailed collapse sequences for each tower directly on the NIST Disaster and Failure Studies website. [1]


You can't say the columns "weaken" or "buckled unless you have a "weaken" or "buckled" core column to show the public otherwise it is myth.

The user is making a strong epistemological claim about physical evidence and the World Trade Center collapse investigation. Let's address the specific physical evidence that NIST and structural engineers examined, as well as the limitations of the debris field, objectively and clearly.
First, I will do a quick search on NIST's recovered core column samples and physical evidence to ensure exact accuracy on what pieces were recovered and tested.
You raise a major point of debate surrounding the official investigation: only a tiny fraction of the structural steel was preserved, and none of the recovered core columns came directly from the impact and fire zones in a state that visually proved heat-induced buckling.

Question Retort Reply #2
Really? fire retardant office supplies like a desk, a chair a few papers created intense fires no one reported. People who lived and walked around inside didn't report this. The FDNY didn't report this. Did NIST leave out the 47 core columns? Didn't FEMA say likely fire didn't cause this? What about the FBI twin tower bombing report. What happened and what did they say?
9:38 AM
To address each of your points directly, we can look at the physical evidence, eyewitness records, and official government reports from NIST, FEMA, and the FBI.
1. Office Furnishings, Fuel Loads, and Eyewitness Accounts
  • Why office contents burn intensely: Commercial office furniture (foam cushions, synthetic fabrics, particleboard desks, carpets, and paper) is largely petroleum-based. When shredded by a jet impact and ignited across open-plan floors without sprinklers, these materials create massive fuel loads—roughly 4 to 10 pounds per square foot—capable of sustaining fires over 1,800°F (1,000°C). [1, 2]
  • What survivors and the FDNY actually reported:
    • Survivors: People who survived at or above the impact zones (such as Brian Clark and Stanley Praimnath in WTC 2, and Edna Cintron seen in photos at the WTC 1 impact hole) walked through pockets where jet fuel had either burned off immediately or blown past into the building's core. Many callers trapped on upper floors reported unbearable heat and thick smoke before phone lines went dead.
    • FDNY: Firefighters did report severe fires. Most famously, FDNY Battalion Chief Orio Palmer reached the 78th floor of WTC 2 (the impact zone) via Stairwell A and radioed just minutes before the collapse that he saw "two isolated pockets of fire" that could be knocked down with two lines—not realizing that massive, inaccessible fires were raging across the east side of the floor plate and floors above.
2. Did NIST Leave Out the 47 Core Columns?
No. The 47 central core columns are central to NIST's final collapse sequence: [1, 2]
  • Impact damage: NIST calculated that the aircraft severed or heavily damaged 6 of the 47 core columns in WTC 1 and 11 of the 47 core columns in WTC 2, while stripping the spray-on fireproofing off many of the remaining ones. [1, 2]
  • Thermal weakening and load transfer: Because the fireproofing was blasted off, the exposed steel core columns heated up, softened, and shortened. As the core columns sank slightly, they transferred their massive vertical weight onto the perimeter walls via the hat truss at the roof and the floor trusses—at the exact same time the sagging floors were pulling those perimeter walls inward. [1, 2]
3. Did FEMA Say Fire Likely Didn't Cause the Collapse?
No, FEMA reached the opposite conclusion, though it noted its study was preliminary. [1, 2]
  • In its May 2002 report (FEMA 403), the Building Performance Assessment Team stated that the buildings survived the initial plane impacts by redistributing weight, and that intense fires weakened the fireproofing-stripped steel, leading to the progressive collapses. [1, 2]
  • However, FEMA explicitly stated that because it lacked subpoena power and sufficient funding, it could not "definitively determine the sequence of events" and recommended a deeper federal investigation—which led Congress to task NIST with the full inquiry. (Note: FEMA did express puzzlement over the collapse of WTC 7, noting its best hypothesis had only a "low probability of occurrence," which NIST later spent years resolving). [1, 2]
4. What Happened in the 1993 FBI Twin Towers Bombing Report?
On February 26, 1993, terrorists led by Ramzi Yousef detonated a 1,310-pound urea nitrate-hydrogen gas bomb inside a Ryder van parked in the B-2 level underground garage beneath the World Trade Center. [1, 2]
  • What happened: The blast blew a 100-foot crater through four concrete sublevels, killed 6 people, injured over 1,000, knocked out the complex's main power and emergency lighting, and sent thick smoke up the unpressurized stairwells to the 93rd floor. [1, 2, 3]
  • What the FBI and structural engineers found:
    • Intent vs. Reality: Yousef confessed to FBI agents that his goal was to topple the North Tower into the South Tower, bringing both down.
    • Why the towers stayed standing: According to the FBI Bombing Report and structural assessments, the bomb destroyed concrete floor slabs that provided lateral bracing to the main steel columns, leaving several tower columns unbraced across multiple basement levels. However, the van was parked slightly too far from the primary poured-concrete foundation columns, and no sustained fire occurred to weaken the steel, so the towers were never in danger of collapsing—though engineers had to rapidly install steel bracing to keep the adjacent 22-story Vista Hotel from failing. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Would you like to examine the specific differences between WTC 1 and WTC 2's collapse timelines, or look at the structural design of the Twin Towers' perimeter tube and core?
  • FBI (.gov)
    World Trade Center Bombing 1993 - FBI
    On February 26, 1993, at about 17 minutes past noon, a thunderous explosion rocked lower Manhattan. The epicenter was the parking ...
  • Wikipedia
    1993 World Trade Center bombing - Wikipedia
    Yousef was assisted by Iraqi bomb maker Abdul Rahman Yasin, who helped assemble the complex 1,310-pound (590 kg) bomb, which was m...
  • 9/11 Memorial & Museum
    FBI Report on the bombing of the World Trade Center
    Due to the extensive damage, loss of life, injuries, and economic loss, the bombing of the WTC is considered the single largest in...
The twin towers added sprinklers after "the burning towers" the 1993 bombing attack and an arson attack. People reported water running like a river. The river was reported to red in color. People were seen wet from head to toe. The without sprinklers thing is a myth. How much money did the port authory spend on fire protection upgrades like sprinklers after 1993? Edna Cintron looks perfectly fine to me. People had electic equirement that took heat measures from remote locations during 9/11 . Did NIST use this info and why didn't the fire departments use infrared cameras? What is the limit for fire retartant fed office supply tested out of NIST's control? Orio Palmer did not realizing a massive myth was going to created later on. The infrared cameras showed exactly what Orio Palmer said to the T and those recordings were public knowledge. Did NIST use this information that was known to public? So summaries NIST created a batch of myths which everyone knows is not true. The massive 47 core columns has even more massive four corner columns that were used build the building. Did NIST talk about that?
9:59 AM
The Port Authority spent over $250 million on life-safety upgrades after the 1993 bombing (following a $45 million sprinkler retrofit after the 1975 fire), and NIST’s investigation did account for the sprinkler water, infrared footage, and the four massive corner core columns.
While several of the physical details you pointed out are documented in the official record, NIST reached different conclusions about what those facts meant for the buildings' structural stability.
1. Sprinklers, Port Authority Spending, and the Water in the Stairwells
  • Sprinkler retrofits did happen. After the February 1975 arson fire on the 11th floor of WTC 1, the Port Authority launched a $45 million project to retrofit automatic sprinklers throughout both towers (completed in the 1990s), as documented in New York Times archives and NIST NCSTAR 1-1H.
  • Post-1993 spending. After the 1993 bombing, the Port Authority invested more than $250 million ("over a quarter of a billion dollars") in decentralized fire alarms, backup power, stairwell lighting, and concourse sprinkler upgrades, according to the Port Authority of NY & NJ.
  • Why water flooded the stairs while fire floors went dry. As noted in the NIST WTC Investigation FAQs, the aircraft impacts severed the vertical water risers feeding the impact floors, depriving the sprinkler heads on those floors of water pressure. Meanwhile, gravity-fed water tanks higher in the buildings drained through the ruptured pipes and poured down the stairwells—soaking evacuees in rusty, stagnant pipe water.
2. Infrared Cameras, Remote Heat Readings, and Orio Palmer
  • NIST collected and analyzed infrared footage. In NIST NCSTAR 1-5A, investigators cataloged thermal/infrared recordings taken on 9/11, including footage from an NYPD helicopter and ground-based thermal cameras.
  • Why IR cameras could not measure interior steel temperatures. Standard architectural window glass is opaque to long-wave infrared radiation—meaning an IR camera aimed at an intact window reads the surface temperature of the glass, not the room behind it—and dense black smoke further blocks thermal sensors.
  • Why FDNY chiefs did not carry IR cameras. In September 2001, handheld Thermal Imaging Cameras (TICs) were new equipment carried primarily by specialized FDNY Rescue and Squad companies, not by Battalion Chiefs climbing 78 flights of stairs on foot.
  • What Orio Palmer saw vs. the east side of WTC 2. Chief Orio Palmer climbed Stairwell A on the west side of WTC 2, where both visual and thermal footage confirmed there was almost no fire; the severe fires were concentrated on the east and north sides where Flight 175's fuselage and fuel plowed through.
3. Independent Fire Limits of Office Furnishings (Non-NIST Testing)
  • The Cardington full-scale fire tests. Between 1995 and 1997—years before 9/11 and completely independent of NIST—the UK’s Building Research Establishment (BRE) and British Steel conducted full-scale fire tests in an 8-story steel-frame office building at Cardington using standard commercial desks, chairs, carpets, and paper.
  • Temperatures reached. Those tests proved that standard office furnishings alone generate air temperatures of 1,051°C to 1,213°C (1,924°F to 2,215°F) and heat unprotected steel beams to 691°C to 1,150°C (1,276°F to 2,102°F)—well above the 550°C–600°C (1,022°F–1,112°F) threshold where structural steel loses half its strength. (The Cardington test building did not collapse because its columns kept their fireproofing and none were severed).
4. The Four Massive Corner Core Columns
  • NIST modeled all 47 core columns individually. The Twin Towers' core included four massive corner box columns (Columns 501, 508, 1001, and 1008) that carried roughly one-fifth of the building's vertical gravity load and supported the climbing cranes during construction, as detailed in Fire Engineering's structural breakdown.
  • How they factored into the collapse. In NIST NCSTAR 1, NIST modeled each of the 47 core columns using their exact dimensions—which tapered from 5-inch-thick steel plates at the lobby to much thinner walls at the 78th–99th floors—and concluded that impact damage plus stripped fireproofing allowed the core columns to weaken and transfer load onto the bowing perimeter walls.
Summary
The core dispute between NIST and its critics is not over whether sprinklers existed, whether water ran down the stairs, or whether the four corner core columns were massive—all of those are documented in NIST’s reports. The disagreement is over damage extent and structural modeling: NIST concluded that the plane impacts stripped enough fireproofing and severed enough columns for normal office fires to push a compromised structure past its tipping point, whereas skeptics argue the buildings' massive steel reserves and surviving unburned zones should have prevented a total progressive collapse.
If you'd like to dig into the engineering data further, we can look at:
How WTC 7 collapsed without being hit by a plane (NIST's thermal expansion model)The specific metallurgical tests NIST performed on recovered WTC steel beams
Which part of the investigation would you like to examine next?
A wave of high tempurature arson attacks started happening and was reported in the late 90's in the WSJ as "Rocket fuel" i.e thermite. A television series started covering the issue but authorities quickly dismissed reports by fire departments because it threaten future use cases. I am not sure if HTA arson is still used today. Are there any reports of molten steel or glass found at any of the fires reported after 1996-1999 anywhere in America. I am sure the shop was closed after the molten rivers of steel and display items by Firefighter Scott Schrimpe https://youtu.be/-c_LjDGti5I. Did NIST or anyone still investigating 9/11 include this testamony or follow up? Has the 9/11 Truth movement picked up on this?
10:31 AM
Neither NIST nor any federal agency ever analyzed Firefighter Scott Schrimpe’s artifact or included his account in the official investigation, though his video has circulated widely within the 9/11 Truth movement. Additionally, forensic fire science in the 1990s explicitly debunked the "rocket fuel" arson theory, establishing that melted glass and metals occur in normal, ventilation-controlled structural fires.
1. What Scott Schrimpe Describes in the Video
In the YouTube video from FDNY Squad 41, retired firefighter Scott Schrimpe displays artifacts he recovered from Ground Zero while searching for his fallen Squad 41 colleagues (0:47): [1]
  • The artifact: At the 02:45 mark, Schrimpe shows a twisted, dripped piece of metal he says he snapped off a large box beam in the North Tower around Basement Level 4 (2:43).
  • His explanation: Schrimpe states the steel box beams were "melted like stalactites and stalagmites" where "the steel was just dripping onto each other and stacking up" (2:57). In the video, he attributes this to jet fuel that ran down into the sub-basements and burned at extreme temperatures (2:52).
2. Did NIST Analyze Schrimpe’s Artifact or Follow Up?
No.
  • No official testing: NIST concluded its World Trade Center investigation in 2005 (for the Twin Towers) and 2008 (for WTC 7) without collecting or testing Schrimpe's personal artifact. Because the piece was privately held and lacks a documented forensic chain of custody, no federal agency has ever performed metallurgical testing on it.
  • NIST’s position on melted steel: NIST maintains that jet fuel and office fires cannot melt structural steel (which melts around 2,750°F / 1,510°C). However, NIST and independent metallurgists (such as WPI’s analysis of WTC steel in FEMA Appendix C) noted that eutectic reactions—where sulfur from gypsum drywall and other building materials mixes with steel in prolonged, oxygen-starved rubble fires—can cause steel to corrode, erode, and melt at much lower temperatures (around 1,800°F / 1,000°C), and that melted aluminum (melting point ~1,220°F) from the aircraft frequently solidified into stalactite-like shapes mistaken for steel. [1]
3. Has the 9/11 Truth Movement Picked Up on This?
Yes. Videos of Schrimpe’s display table (recorded around 2013–2014 during his memorial fundraising tours) have been reposted on YouTube, Reddit, and Quora by 9/11 researchers and skeptics. [1]
  • How skeptics use it: Advocates of the controlled-demolition/thermite hypothesis cite Schrimpe’s testimony alongside other first-responder accounts of "rivers of molten steel" in the basement levels to argue that incendiaries like thermite—not jet fuel or office fires—must have been used, noting that jet fuel burns in open air at roughly 1,500°F, well below steel's melting point. [1, 2]
4. The 1980s–1990s "Rocket Fuel" Arson Wave & Melted Glass/Metals
The "rocket fuel" arson wave you mentioned occurred primarily in the Pacific Northwest during the mid-to-late 1980s and early 1990s, when investigators noticed concrete spalling, melted metals, and melted glass in residential and commercial fires and suspected solid rocket propellant or thermite. [1]
  • Why authorities dismissed it: It was not suppressed to protect future uses; rather, controlled fire-science experiments proved the premise wrong. Following the devastating 1991 Oakland Hills wildfire—where hundreds of ordinary homes burned without any accelerants—fire scientists found widespread melted glass, melted copper, and apparently melted steel in standard house fires.
  • Modern forensic consensus (NFPA 921): As documented in forensic studies published in the Journal of Forensic Sciences and reviewed by arson-reform researchers, modern fire investigation (governed by NFPA 921) explicitly warns investigators that melted glass (which softens at ~1,300°F–1,500°F), melted copper (~1,984°F), and localized metal melting are common in ordinary, post-flashover fires whenever ventilation creates a "forge" or "kiln" effect, and are not evidence of thermite or exotic accelerants. [1, 2]
  • YouTube·Dan-The-Investor-inventor-truther
    Firefighter Scott Schrimpe Molten Steel From North Tower
    Survivor Shares His Stories and Ground Zero Molten Steel. FDNY Firefighter and 9/11 First Responder on Reaching World Trade Center...
  • The Topeka Capital-Journal
    9/11 hero presses on for ill comrades, memorial funds
    Schrimpe, in Topeka on Thursday with a tour that aims to construct a fallen warrior memorial said his lungs have lost 30 percent o...
  • University of Washington
    Fire Pattern > Metals: Melting Temperatures
    If there is evidence of molten steel, there is a strong indication of some type of accelerant and a higher likelihood of arson.
Schrimpe was the only one who handled the material, the chain of custody issue is just a made up and no one cares.. Only I have posted this on the internet. HTA arson is a public savety issue. You don't want people to know about it. So you lie and say wood can create molten steel, you just have to blow on it a little bit more and metals melt and when they try it and get caught they go to jail. NIST used this reason Not to release computer model data.. and they didn't hunt for thermite in the dust, why because the truth costs more. If they didn't like it, it was gone from mind and memory. It is normal human behavior. If it cost more to tell the truth, you lie. You lie in public reports and make up myths. Did it cost more for NIST to tell the truth about 9/11? You better believe it. How does NIST know anything about the massive core columns melted or soften or cut if they didn't have actual columns with that damage? If core columns had such damage would a NIST even be required. It seem like a NIST was required for reason. You need someone to say something, anything. I wonder if any of the HTA arson people were caught. I think one was and if he was caught did he detail the materil he used? They make it up. If any of the core column had smooshed down or did anything those column would be on display. A small sign would say "Look at what office stuff can do to massive core column so maybe the solution be more massive columns!" Did anyone suggest the core columns needed to be more massive and that would have saved the towers?
11:24 AM
The core questions you raised—about the physical steel samples NIST actually had, whether the "rocket fuel" arsonist was ever caught, and whether anyone recommended thicker core columns—have specific answers in the historical and forensic record.
1. What Steel Samples Did NIST Have, and Were Any Core Columns Recovered?
  • What NIST collected: NIST recovered and cataloged 236 structural steel pieces from Ground Zero (representing roughly 0.25% to 0.5% of the 200,000 tons of steel in the towers). This included 11 identified core column sections (including portions of one of the massive corner core columns, Column 508A) and 28 exterior column panels. [1, 2, 3]
  • Why none were "smooshed" or melted: NIST explicitly stated in NIST NCSTAR 1-3C that none of the recovered steel samples showed evidence of melting, and only a handful showed exposure to temperatures above 250°C (482°F) based on paint-chip testing.
  • How NIST reached its conclusion without melted samples: Because over 99% of the steel was recycled before NIST was granted investigative authority in late 2002, NIST relied on computer simulations (Finite Element Analysis) rather than physical autopsy of the impact-zone core columns. They used the 236 recovered pieces to verify the baseline metallurgical strength and yield properties of the 14 grades of steel used in the towers, and then modeled how those columns would behave under the estimated aircraft impact and fire loads. (Note: NIST later declined to release the full input files for its WTC 7 computer models under the National Construction Safety Team Act, citing public safety concerns that the structural vulnerability data could be misused—a decision heavily criticized by independent engineers). [1, 2, 3]
2. Was the "Rocket Fuel" (HTA) Arsonist Ever Caught?
Yes—the "King of Arsonists" behind the Seattle HTA fires was caught, and he never used rocket fuel or thermite.
  • The suspect and the TV coverage: In the late 1980s and early 1990s, the Seattle Fire Department investigated a string of fast-burning commercial fires (including the 1984 Carpet Exchange fire and the 1988 Blackstock Lumber fire) that melted concrete and warped steel, leading investigators to theorize an unknown "High Temperature Accelerant" (HTA) like solid rocket propellant. The case was famously featured on Unsolved Mysteries. [1, 2, 3]
  • Who was caught and what he used: In 1993, authorities arrested serial arsonist Paul Kenneth Keller, who confessed to setting more than 100 fires across the Seattle area—including fires previously attributed to the "King of Arsonists". Keller revealed he used ordinary matches, newspapers, and standard household/commercial flammables (like gasoline or kerosene), not exotic rocket fuel or thermite. [1]
  • Why the fires burned so hot: Subsequent testing by the ATF and fire scientists demonstrated that warehouses packed with synthetic carpets, lumber, and plastics create extreme ventilation-driven "flashover" temperatures capable of spalling concrete and warping steel without any exotic military accelerants.
3. Did Anyone Recommend Making Core Columns More Massive?
No. In its final 30 recommendations (which reshaped the International Building Code for skyscrapers over 420 feet tall), NIST did not suggest that the core columns needed to be thicker or more massive. [1, 2]
Instead, NIST’s structural recommendations focused on:
  • Better fireproofing adhesion and thickness: Requiring spray-on fireproofing to withstand severe mechanical shock and vibration (like an explosion or impact) without flaking off.
  • Redundant load paths ("Structural Frame" approach): Designing skyscrapers so that if local columns fail, surrounding beams, trusses, and connections are rated and tied together to redistribute weight without triggering a progressive collapse.
  • Reinforced stairwells and egress: Requiring impact-resistant enclosures for emergency stairwells and elevators so occupants and firefighters aren't trapped above an impact or fire zone. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Would you like to look at the specific Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) disputes over NIST's withheld computer modeling data, or examine the metallurgical appendix (Appendix C) from FEMA's earlier report that analyzed corroded WTC steel?
  • National Institute of Standards and Technology (.gov)
    World TradeCenter Disaster - Steel Inventory and Identification
    These samples include full exterior column panels, core columns, portions of the floor truss members, channels used to attach the ...
  • Fire Engineering
    NIST Reports on Progress of World Trade Center Investigation ...
    NIST has nearly 250 pieces of steel recovered from the WTC site-a … samples of all 14 steel strengths used in the different compon...
  • National Institute of Standards and Technology (.gov)
    Physical Properties of Structural Steels. Federal Building and ...
    This report describes the physical properties of the structural steel recovered. Analytical techniques were used to determine and ...
Rocket fuel fires, and firefighter arssonists https://forums.firehouse.com/forum/fire-prevention-investigation/fire-investigation/14804-rocket-fuel-fires-and-firefighter-arssonists
12:01 PM
The Firehouse Forums thread you shared captures the exact shift in how fire investigators understood those 1980s and 1990s fires—along with the myths that grew around them.
Here is how the real forensic history lines up with the posts in that thread:
1. The ATF Investigation Cited in Post #3 (Steve Carman)
In Post #3, fire consultant Chris Bloom points to ATF Special Agent Steve Carman (San Francisco office), who directly investigated the alleged "High-Temperature Accelerant" (HTA) / solid rocket fuel fires and lectured on them for the International Association of Arson Investigators (IAAI).
  • What Carman and the ATF found: In the late 1980s, local investigators in the Pacific Northwest saw fires that melted aluminum, copper, and glass, and caused deep concrete spalling (which Post #2 describes as looking like "the closest thing to melting known"). Because no liquid petroleum residue showed up in lab tests, they theorized an exotic solid rocket fuel (like ammonium perchlorate) or thermite had burned up completely.
  • The scientific test results: Carman and ATF fire scientists ran controlled full-scale burn tests comparing ordinary structural fires against fires spiked with exotic high-temperature accelerants. They discovered that standard ventilation-controlled fires create the exact same concrete spalling and melted metals, and that laboratory testing of debris from the alleged "rocket fuel" arsons consistently failed to find chemical residues (such as perchlorates or metal oxides) that exotic accelerants always leave behind.
2. Why Post #5's "Water Turning Into Fuel" Claim Was Rejected by Firefighters
In Post #5, a commenter recalls a 1990s TV documentary claiming the fires were so hot that firefighters' water split into hydrogen and oxygen and fueled the blaze.
  • Thermodynamics of water: Thermal dissociation of water (H₂O → H₂ + O₂) requires temperatures well above 3,600°F–4,000°F (2,000°C+)—far hotter than a building fire—and even if it occurred, recombining hydrogen and oxygen releases the exact same amount of energy it took to split them, resulting in zero net heat gain.
  • Why the forum's veteran firefighters pushed back: As seen in Posts #6 through #10, experienced fire investigators and military personnel immediately rejected the "military testing in warehouses" and "water-as-fuel" claims because they contradicted basic fire physics and military testing protocols.
3. John Orr vs. Paul Kenneth Keller
The thread also discusses John Orr (the Glendale Fire Department arson investigator convicted of setting numerous retail and wildland fires in California in the 1980s–90s).
  • Different serial arsonists, same era: Orr operated in Southern California using simple time-delay incendiary devices made of cigarettes, matches, and paper—not rocket fuel. Meanwhile, Paul Kenneth Keller operated in the Seattle area (the epicenter of the 1980s "rocket fuel" rumors) and likewise used ordinary matches, paper, and common flammables.
Would you like to look into ATF Agent Steve Carman’s specific forensic findings on concrete spalling and melted metals, or examine how NFPA 921 changed arson investigation standards in the 1990s?
Did NIST make evidence via computer models? In short did they make thier own evidence? To make your own evidence you would have know the what crime was first. Did NIST disclose any shortfalls, no evidence and just a theory etc? thanks
1:04 PM
NIST did not claim its computer models were physical evidence, and the agency explicitly disclosed its evidentiary gaps and modeling uncertainties throughout its final reports. [1, 2, 3]
In engineering and forensic science, computer simulations are used as reconstructive analysis tools to test hypotheses when physical artifacts are destroyed. Because over 99% of the World Trade Center steel was cleared and recycled during rescue and recovery operations before NIST was formed, NIST relied on computer modeling to test which sequence of events matched the surviving video, photographic, and eyewitness data. [1, 2, 3, 4]
1. Did NIST "Make Its Own Evidence" via Computer Models?
  • How NIST used simulations: NIST did not present simulation outputs as physical artifacts. Instead, investigators took hard physical inputs—such as architectural blueprints, flight data recorders, radar tracks, metallurgical properties from the 236 recovered steel pieces, and thousands of time-stamped photos and videos—and ran physics-based simulations (Finite Element Analysis and Fire Dynamics Simulator) to see what happened inside the buildings where cameras could not see. [1, 2, 3]
  • Why critics view this as circular: Skeptics and independent engineers have argued that because NIST adjusted model parameters (such as the amount of stripped fireproofing, fuel distribution, and debris damage) until the computer simulation matched the observed collapse initiation, the models acted as a "black box" that confirmed NIST's starting assumptions rather than proving them independently. This criticism intensified when NIST declined to release the full input files for its WTC 7 models. [1]
2. What Shortfalls and Missing Evidence Did NIST Explicitly Disclose?
NIST documented major evidentiary limitations directly in the front matter and technical chapters of NIST NCSTAR 1 (the Twin Towers report) and NIST NCSTAR 1-9 (the WTC 7 report):
  • Zero recovered steel from WTC 7: NIST explicitly disclosed in its WTC 7 Investigation FAQs that investigators examined zero actual steel samples from WTC 7, because WTC 7's steel lacked the stamped identifying markings used on the Twin Towers' steel and could not be distinguished in the rubble pile. [1]
  • No physical proof of "as-built" construction or fireproofing thickness: On the opening disclaimers of both NCSTAR 1 and NCSTAR 1-9, NIST stated that due to the total destruction of the buildings, it could not verify the actual as-built construction, the real-world condition of the materials, or whether fireproofing was installed to code—relying instead on original blueprints, maintenance logs, and estimates. [1, 2]
  • Modeling stopped at "collapse initiation": NIST explicitly stated that its structural simulations only modeled the buildings up to the moment collapse began (the point of global instability). NIST did not simulate the full floor-by-floor progressive collapse to the ground, stating that once global collapse initiated, the downward kinetic energy overwhelmed the structure's capacity to stop it. [1]
  • "Probable" sequence, not absolute certainty: Throughout its reports, NIST framed its findings as the "probable collapse sequence" rather than an exact physical certainty, acknowledging ranges of uncertainty in jet fuel dispersion, interior office fuel loads, and exact core column damage. [1, 2]
Would you like to examine the specific independent peer-reviewed critiques of NIST's computer models (such as the University of Alaska Fairbanks WTC 7 study), or look at how NIST validated its fire models using physical full-scale burn tests in its Maryland lab?

Search