Did NIST make evidence via computer models? In short did they make thier own evidence? To make your own evidence you would have know the what crime was first. Did NIST disclose any shortfalls, no evidence and just a theory etc? thanks
NIST did not claim its computer models were physical evidence, and the agency explicitly disclosed its evidentiary gaps and modeling uncertainties throughout its final reports. [1, 2, 3]
In engineering and forensic science, computer simulations are used as reconstructive analysis tools to test hypotheses when physical artifacts are destroyed. Because over 99% of the World Trade Center steel was cleared and recycled during rescue and recovery operations before NIST was formed, NIST relied on computer modeling to test which sequence of events matched the surviving video, photographic, and eyewitness data. [1, 2, 3, 4]
1. Did NIST "Make Its Own Evidence" via Computer Models?
- How NIST used simulations: NIST did not present simulation outputs as physical artifacts. Instead, investigators took hard physical inputs—such as architectural blueprints, flight data recorders, radar tracks, metallurgical properties from the 236 recovered steel pieces, and thousands of time-stamped photos and videos—and ran physics-based simulations (Finite Element Analysis and Fire Dynamics Simulator) to see what happened inside the buildings where cameras could not see. [1, 2, 3]
- Why critics view this as circular: Skeptics and independent engineers have argued that because NIST adjusted model parameters (such as the amount of stripped fireproofing, fuel distribution, and debris damage) until the computer simulation matched the observed collapse initiation, the models acted as a "black box" that confirmed NIST's starting assumptions rather than proving them independently. This criticism intensified when NIST declined to release the full input files for its WTC 7 models. [1]
2. What Shortfalls and Missing Evidence Did NIST Explicitly Disclose?
NIST documented major evidentiary limitations directly in the front matter and technical chapters of NIST NCSTAR 1 (the Twin Towers report) and NIST NCSTAR 1-9 (the WTC 7 report):
- Zero recovered steel from WTC 7: NIST explicitly disclosed in its WTC 7 Investigation FAQs that investigators examined zero actual steel samples from WTC 7, because WTC 7's steel lacked the stamped identifying markings used on the Twin Towers' steel and could not be distinguished in the rubble pile. [1]
- No physical proof of "as-built" construction or fireproofing thickness: On the opening disclaimers of both NCSTAR 1 and NCSTAR 1-9, NIST stated that due to the total destruction of the buildings, it could not verify the actual as-built construction, the real-world condition of the materials, or whether fireproofing was installed to code—relying instead on original blueprints, maintenance logs, and estimates. [1, 2]
- Modeling stopped at "collapse initiation": NIST explicitly stated that its structural simulations only modeled the buildings up to the moment collapse began (the point of global instability). NIST did not simulate the full floor-by-floor progressive collapse to the ground, stating that once global collapse initiated, the downward kinetic energy overwhelmed the structure's capacity to stop it. [1]
- "Probable" sequence, not absolute certainty: Throughout its reports, NIST framed its findings as the "probable collapse sequence" rather than an exact physical certainty, acknowledging ranges of uncertainty in jet fuel dispersion, interior office fuel loads, and exact core column damage. [1, 2]
Question #2
It sounds like they made the evidence or what evidence they had and you just detailed what they did. Normally the evidence can rest on a table. It is called the evidence table. Since the evidence NIST had was gone and therefore could not rest on a evidence table it was made by [add the list you just mentioned] Only a few pieces could be considered imporant. Random 236 steel pieces of which none were massive core columns weaken by office fires i.e considered key evidence. The other random 236 steel were they all parts from a floor? NIST never said 2. they have zero evidence and 3. outside the stuff they made they have no grounds believe what they believe.
1:23 PM
You are pointing directly to the core epistemological divide between a traditional criminal investigation—where physical murder weapons or intact fire-damaged beams are tagged and laid out on an "evidence table"—and how NIST conducted a post-collapse structural failure analysis.
Here is the exact breakdown of what those 236 pieces actually were, what was physically on NIST's "evidence table," and why NIST's conclusions remain contested.
1. What Were the 236 Steel Pieces? (Were They All Floor Parts?)
No, they were not all floor parts—most were exterior perimeter columns. According to NIST NCSTAR 1-3B, the 236 recovered steel pieces consisted of:
- ~90 exterior perimeter column panels (the three-story, three-column prefabricated steel sections that formed the outer walls of the towers—including 42 panels from directly inside or immediately adjacent to the aircraft impact zones).
- ~55 floor truss sections (the open-web steel joists that supported the concrete floor slabs).
- ~11 interior core column sections (including portions of one of the massive corner core box columns, Column 508A, though from lower/upper undamaged floors rather than the impact zone).
- ~80 miscellaneous pieces (bolts, diagonal bracing, spandrel plates, and unidentified fragments).
2. What Was Physically on NIST's "Evidence Table"?
While NIST did not have fire-softened core columns from the impact zones, it did rely on several categories of hard physical and recorded evidence rather than computer models alone:
- Impact-damaged exterior columns: NIST physically examined dozens of recovered exterior wall panels from the exact aircraft entry holes. Investigators measured the inward bowing, shear fractures, and impact deformation on these beams to verify the exact speed, angle, and structural damage caused by the Boeing 767s.
- Paint-chip temperature forensics: NIST tested the primer paint on 170 locations across the recovered impact-zone exterior columns and floor trusses. Because primer paint cracks and mud-cracks at known temperatures (specifically around 250°C / 482°F), NIST used these physical pieces to map where steel stayed cool versus where it heated up.
- Time-stamped visual and audio records: NIST cataloged over 6,800 photographs and 300+ hours of video, plus FDNY radio transmissions and 911 call logs. These recordings physically documented the inward bowing of the exterior walls (visible in high-resolution photos of WTC 1's south wall and WTC 2's east wall minutes before collapse) and the exact sequence of window breakages and fire spread.
3. Why Your Critique Mirrors the Core Argument of Engineering Skeptics
Your point—that without the actual fire-damaged core columns and floor connections on an evidence table, NIST’s computer simulations essentially constructed the proof of its own hypothesis—is the exact critique raised by structural engineers and researchers who challenged the report:
- Unverifiable assumptions: Because NIST had no physical steel from WTC 7 and no fire-weakened core columns from the Twin Towers' impact zones, investigators had to assume how much fireproofing was knocked off, assume how hot the interior fires burned, and tune the computer inputs until the virtual building buckled.
- No physical "smoking gun": NIST never stated it had "zero evidence" because it treated the exterior wall bowing photos, impact-zone perimeter steel, and collapse videos as evidence. However, NIST did acknowledge it lacked the physical interior steel needed to directly prove core failure, leaving computer simulation as the only bridge between the visible exterior damage and total collapse.
Would you like to examine the specific inward-bowing photographs of the perimeter walls that NIST cited as its primary physical proof before collapse, or look at how WTC 7's collapse was modeled without any recovered steel at all?
No comments:
Post a Comment